guitarsandbourbon
Follow Me:
  • Blog
  • Artist Archive
  • About
  • Contact

Brady vs Manning

10/5/2013

4 Comments

 
Picture
Picture
My Kentucky readers sometimes forget that its football season (how 'bout that slogan "This is why we camp" at Big Blue Madness?"), but here we are in week 5 of the NFL season.  Last week, Tom Brady and the Pats took on the Dirty Birds from Atlanta and Peyton Manning and the seemingly unstoppable Denver Broncos took on the Philadelphia Eagles.  Why are these two so interesting, besides them being in the top tier of elite quarterbacks who consistently win games for their teams and break NFL records?  I'll tell you.

Peyton Manning, who was deemed by some to forever be "the mystery of the Bionic Neck", comes to Denver and completely changes their team.  The guy is on fire; through only 4 games Manning has completed 117 passes out of 156 attempts (that's 75% completion) for 1470 yards and 16 touchdowns.  WHAT?  Yes.  Oh, also he has zero interceptions and has a quarterback rating of 138.  That's stinkin' good.  Don't ask me about this stupid scale, but 158.3 is perfect.  

But when I'm older I'm not going to be telling my kids and grandkids about Manning's stats.  They will have access to the numbers.  I'm going to be telling them the stories about watching Peyton Manning, who people thought was past his prime, unequivocally control football games.  If you haven't been watching this guy, you need to.  I will forever hold onto memories of him crouched behind his center, eyeing the defense, then inventing a new play.  The man swivels his partially mechanical neck, then shouts things like "ZEBRA! ZEBRA!" or "OMAHA!" and then picks apart the confused defense.  The guy knows football arguably better than anyone else in the history of the game, and nobody else controls games like him.

Picture
While Manning is in his 16th season, Tom Brady is in his 14th.  At first, their 2013 seasons don't compare; Brady is 93 of 158 (58.9% completion) for 1014 yards, 7 touchdowns and 2 interceptions.  But the difference lies in Brady's track record and some more intangibles. Brady brought his team to 5 Superbowls, and won 3 of them, twice making Superbowl MVP.  Peyton has only 2 Superbowl appearances and one Superbowl win (as well as the MVP award).  This alone would lead some to argue that Brady is better, but I wouldn't leave it at that.

Tom Brady's stats are hardly fair; I watched 3 of the 4 games so far, and Brady is hitting his receivers' hands.  He's that good.  So why so few completions?  Well, Julian Edelman is Brady's only trusted receiver through the first 4 games.  Rob Gronkowski has been injured, and Danny Amendola, who was brought on with the loss of Wes Welker, is new to the Patriots AND injured.  Oh yea, did I mention the Pats gave up Wes Welker, Dieon Branch and Matthew Slater?  Tom is playing, yet again, with an almost fresh set of wide receivers.  I tried to find the number of different receivers that Brady has completed a pass to, but all I found was this article which goes into some depth on the subject.  That guy really loves the Patriots.  The number itself isn't as important as the implication, and that is that Tom Brady makes players around him great.

Brady has played with a higher receiver turnover rate than Peyton Manning (or any other QB, for that matter) and yet he continues to make them great.  The improvements in the Patriots' receivers over the first 4 weeks is testament to his impact on his teammates.  This is why these two are so interesting:  Manning controls games with a confidence and effectiveness that confuses and overwhelms defenses; and Tom Brady seems to be such a talented QB and inspiring leader that the players around him improve constantly.  Keep in mind that Peyton Manning's receivers on the current Denver Broncos squad are some of the best in the game, with Wes Welker, Demarius Thomas and Eric Decker just to name three.  So who's the better quarterback?  That's up to you, tell me what you think!

4 Comments
Marisa
10/5/2013 09:52:05 am

I must say that I doubted Peyton's recovery after surgery, but clearly something was implanted in his neck to bring him to a whole different level. Very happy he is on my fantasy team this year :).
Tom Brady is also an exceptional QB who can clearly step up to the plate in big games, but he is nowhere near Peyton status... really, nobody is (Brees can come close sometimes, but I'm still bitter about his 2-picks per game last season that destroyed my fantasy team). Also, keep in mind that Brady has Belichick coaching him. To my dismay, I have to admit that he is one of the top 2 coaches currently in the game. Also, when Brady won his Superbowls, keep in mind that he had a great support team every year.
Peyton just gets football, plain and simple. His accuracy is incredible and his eye for future plays is unsurpassed. He can pick apart a defense like nobody I've ever seen. He is one of the few players who can make any team he plays for achieve a >.500 season.

Reply
advancedwriters link
4/10/2020 12:00:50 am

If you ask me, Tom Brady is definitely the better quarterback between the two. Sure, he wasn't as explosive as other quarterbacks, but when it came to intelligence and sheer game knowledge, Tom Brady is virtually unparalleled. I am thinking about making things better from now on, but believe me, it is hard for me to see him lose sight of what he wants to do. I hope that he becomes a better player still. He is old, but he still has game.

Reply
Sela
10/5/2013 12:38:47 pm

K--so I believe you you need to add football to guitars and bourbon--and btw--they all go together!! As far as Peyton Manning verses Tom Brady...My opinion --Manning is so far superior it isnt even close---maybe this is coming from age and experience superiority but it could also comes from attitude (or lack thereof) Peyton is (or seems to be) the kind of person you want to marrry, want your daughter to marry, or want your son son to emulate..not so much Tom Brady...And if you throw in Drew Brees---well like Peyton...

Reply
Uncle David
10/7/2013 07:16:51 am

Brady and Manning are both excellent Q-Backs. How about Teddy Bridgewater?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Travis

    Thanks for visiting my blog about music, bourbon, football, and everything in between!

    Archives

    February 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Beer
    Bourbon
    Country
    Entertainment
    Food
    Football
    Kentucky
    Music
    Rock
    Smoke
    Sports
    Strings
    Vocals


Proudly powered by Weebly